1705 Heath Parkway, Fort Collins, CO 970-402-8267
Contact us
The Soukup Group
Tailored to Relocating
For sale · single-familyFort Collins, CO 80525

2556 Nancy Gray Ave

Read for someone moving in — the cost-of-living math, schools and commute, so you can weigh it before you book a flight.
New listing
$735,000
List price · $4,305 / yr/yr tax · $80 / mo
4Bedrooms
4Bathrooms
2,873Sq ft
2Garage
$256 / sqftPrice / sq ft
2016Year built
0.11 acLot size
Open house
Sat Oct 1011:00 AM–2:00 PMSun Oct 1111:00 AM–2:00 PM
279 views17 saved

More interior photos coming Friday after new carpet is installed. Welcome to Bucking Horse, the Fort Collins neighborhood built around the old Jessup Farm, where morning coffee, date-night pizza, and summer nights at the pool are all a stroll from your door. This Craftsman-style two-story lives easy: a rocking-chair front porch, hardwood floors, and an open main level warmed by a stone fireplace with a mantel cut from the wood of the original Jessup Farm barn. A little piece of history that newer homes almost never get. Thoughtful design shows throughout: a wall of windows pours light across the great room, which stretches to seat the whole crew when the holidays land at your house. The main-floor primary suite is a quiet oasis all its own. Upstairs, two more bedrooms share a full bath, and the finished basement adds a big rec room, guest bedroom, and bath. Out back, a string-lit courtyard with a fire pit connects the house to its oversized two-car garage. The fenced yard is sized for a garden and a game of fetch, not a weekend of mowing. Dovetail Park deserves its own mention, four minutes away on foot, with a great playground, the community gardens, and a tucked-away calm that makes it perfect for a picnic. Lock and leave for the mountains, bike the Power Trail, and let Jessup Farm's award-winning spots become your regulars. New carpet throughout the house, tankless hot water, and a quality build that shows. And it's all smack dab in the middle of Fort Collins: Old Town, CSU, and I-25 are about ten minutes away. Easy to live in, easy to leave for adventure from, and always a pleasure to come home to. More interior photos coming Friday after new carpet is installed.

Gallery & media

See it for yourself.

About this home

2556 Nancy Gray Ave

Coming soon

5 properties matched to you, after the quiz.

Hand-picked by Patrick — not algorithm-generic. Sorted by your persona profile.

60/100FOR SALE

$500,000

193 W Boardwalk Dr · Fort Collins


Walkability: 74 (10 of 10)
Flood-safe: 1 (4 of 10)
Mild winters: 14 days/yr (5 of 10)
FOR SALE

$525,000

1281 E 21st Ct · Loveland

4 BD · 2 BA · 4,072 SF

FOR SALE

$525,000

2239 Friar Tuck Ct · Fort Collins

3 BD · 4 BA · 3,479 SF

FOR SALE

$535,000

290 Clark Ct · Windsor

4 BD · 3 BA · 3,336 SF

FOR SALE

$509,000

204 N Jefferson Ave · Loveland

3 BD · 2 BA · 1,744 SF

Your guide
Listing agent
Soukup Real Estate
License pending

Want to walk 2556 Nancy in person?

Modeled value, rent and projections are estimates produced by The Soukup Group's own model — not appraisals, not financial advice, and not third-party valuations. Ranges and confidence reflect real uncertainty. Equal Housing Opportunity.

The Soukup Group© 2026 The Soukup Group · Powered by eXp RealtyEqual Housing Opportunity