1705 Heath Parkway, Fort Collins, CO 970-402-8267
Contact us
The Soukup Group
Tailored to Relocating
For sale · single-familyFort Collins, CO 80525

2556 Nancy Gray Ave

Read for someone moving in — the cost-of-living math, schools and commute, so you can weigh it before you book a flight.
39 days on market
$715,000
List price · $4,305 / yr tax · $80 / mo
4Bedrooms
4Bathrooms
2,892Sq ft
2Garage
$247 / sqftPrice / sq ft
2016Year built
0.11 acLot size
Open house
Sat Nov 1411:00 AM–2:00 PM
Our statistical model*
$638,000based on what similar homes sold for

*Based on a mathematical and statistical model: machine learning trained on 15,000 local sales. Not intended as an appraisal.

Asking $715k

Half between $601k and $691k

What similar homes support16 similar homes, priced to today's marketUnusual sale

The asking price is above what similar homes support. On its own that doesn't mean it won't sell near asking: homes priced above that range sold for about 99% of their asking.

This listing's history adds context: 39 days on the market without an accepted offer (similar-priced homes got one in 10 days) and 2 price cuts.

What "similar homes" means here

Detached homes with 4 bedrooms, 1,210 to 2,250 sq ft above ground (within 30% of this home), built 1991 to 2026, sold in the last 12 months. We start within 1 mile and widen, up to 3 miles, until there are at least 12. Here: 2 miles, 16 homes.

These rules were picked by testing them against 2,275 real sales.

Why $638,000

  • Similar homes' median, priced to today's market$670.4k
  • Location: homes nearest this one sell for more+$9.1k
  • Age and condition+$3.0k
  • Size+$4.1k
  • Other details and model fine-tuning-$48.6k
  • Our statistical model$638.0k

Tested on 1,200 real sales: half sold within 7.5% of our estimate.

Easy in, easy living. This Bucking Horse two-story keeps the best of everything on one level: an open floor plan with wood floors, a granite countertop kitchen with island seating, and a main floor primary suite, no stairs between you and your morning coffee. Built by a local builder, not a national production line, extremely well maintained, and 100% move-in ready. Upstairs, two bedrooms and a full bath give kids or guests their own territory. The finished basement multiplies your options: a big rec room, a conforming bedroom with egress, and a full bath that live like a separate space, equally good as a hobby space and guest wing, a multi-generational living setup, or a roommate arrangement with real privacy, plus a big storage room for everything else. Out back, a string-lit courtyard with a fire pit connects the house to its oversized two-car garage, and the fenced yard is sized for low maintenance living, more weekends, less mowing. Then there's the neighborhood, and fair warning: people who land in Bucking Horse rarely want to leave it. A pool down the street, parks and trails out the door, restaurants and coffee a stroll away, and all of it about ten minutes from Old Town, CSU, and I-25. A primary on main, a flexible finished basement, and room for however your household actually lives.

Gallery & media

See it for yourself.

About this home

2556 Nancy Gray Ave

Coming soon

5 properties matched to you, after the quiz.

Hand-picked by Patrick — not algorithm-generic. Sorted by your persona profile.

60/100FOR SALE

$500,000

193 W Boardwalk Dr · Fort Collins


Walkability: 74 (10 of 10)
Flood-safe: 1 (4 of 10)
Mild winters: 14 days/yr (5 of 10)
FOR SALE

$525,000

1281 E 21st Ct · Loveland

4 BD · 2 BA · 4,072 SF

FOR SALE

$510,000

630 N Franklin Ave · Loveland

5 BD · 2 BA · 2,376 SF

FOR SALE

$509,000

204 N Jefferson Ave · Loveland

3 BD · 2 BA · 1,744 SF

FOR SALE

$519,900

109 Princeton Rd · Fort Collins

3 BD · 2 BA · 1,778 SF

Your guide
Listing agent
Soukup Real Estate
License pending

Want to walk 2556 Nancy in person?

Modeled value, rent and projections are estimates produced by The Soukup Group's own model — not appraisals, not financial advice, and not third-party valuations. Ranges and confidence reflect real uncertainty. Equal Housing Opportunity.

The Soukup Group© 2026 The Soukup Group · Powered by eXp RealtyEqual Housing Opportunity