1705 Heath Parkway, Fort Collins, CO 970-402-8267
Contact us
The Soukup Group
Tailored to Relocating
For sale · single-familyWindsor, CO 80550

33741 Highway 257

Read for someone moving in — the cost-of-living math, schools and commute, so you can weigh it before you book a flight.
12 days on market
$1,200,000
List price · $4,582 / yr/yr tax · No HOA
4Bedrooms
3Bathrooms
2,805Sq ft
4Garage
$428 / sqftPrice / sq ft
1899Year built
6.07 acLot size
168 views13 saved

For years, people came here looking for a Christmas tree. They usually left with something more.Haywagon rides through the trees. Cider by the fire. Moonlight Christmas caroling. Kids skating on the pond. Reunions, long walks, and countless reasons to gather. This 6.07-acre Windsor property has always been a place where people slow down and make memories.Now someone new gets to decide what happens next.The approximately 2,800-square-foot home began as an 1898 homestead and has grown over generations. Today it offers generous kitchen, dining and living spaces, a solar sunroom, two bedrooms and two baths, plus an attached mother-in-law addition with another bedroom, bath, living area, office and kitchenette-style space.But outside is where this property becomes nearly impossible to duplicate. Mature trees and vegetation create remarkable privacy, while two ponds and a complete irrigation system add beauty and function. Multiple substantial outbuildings provide garage, workshop and storage space, including the heated Quonset building once used for Christmas tree sales.Continue the agricultural tradition, explore allowable business uses, or keep all six acres as your own private retreat. Grow a garden. Tinker in the shop. Gather your people around the pond. Walk beneath trees planted and cared for over generations.The owners call it "a little slice of peace and tranquility in the hustle and bustle of the Front Range." After decades of Christmas traditions, reunions, hard work and people simply enjoying one another, that may be its most valuable feature.The Christmas trees brought people here. The place gave them a reason to stay.Now it's someone else's turn to write the next chapter.

Gallery & media

See it for yourself.

About this home

33741 Highway 257

Coming soon

5 properties matched to you, after the quiz.

Hand-picked by Patrick — not algorithm-generic. Sorted by your persona profile.

64/100FOR SALE

$1,175,000

508 W Olive St · Fort Collins

7 BD · 4 BA · 3,414 SF


Walkability: 87 (10 of 10)
Square footage: 3,414 sqft (7 of 10)
Flood-safe: 1 (4 of 10)
FOR SALE

$890,000

135 Cleveland Ave · Loveland

4,180 SF

FOR SALE

$899,000

610 S Sherwood St · Fort Collins

7 BD · 4 BA · 2,721 SF

FOR SALE

$750,000

601 S Whitcomb St · Fort Collins

3,120 SF

FOR SALE

$925,000

214-216 7th St · Windsor

10 BD · 5 BA · 7,333 SF

Your guide
Listing agent
Soukup Real Estate
License pending

Want to walk 33741 Highway in person?

Modeled value, rent and projections are estimates produced by The Soukup Group's own model — not appraisals, not financial advice, and not third-party valuations. Ranges and confidence reflect real uncertainty. Equal Housing Opportunity.

The Soukup Group© 2026 The Soukup Group · Powered by eXp RealtyEqual Housing Opportunity